We May Have Lost Already


The internet as we know it today became prominent around 1993. I was 15 years old, and I started making my living from it just a few years later . . . which means that I’ve been working in this space for the majority of my life – over 30 years.

I used to enjoy going online. The connections I made with people were almost always positive. I learned new and interesting things. I witnessed creativity and beauty in so many forms. I spent many years building philanthropic communities, creating space for people to love one another. I think we really did change the world in some small way. I know we changed mine.

But now? Going online – which isn’t as much a thing that we do, so much as a thing that we are – feels like walking through raw sewage in bare feet. It’s disgusting. I’m not even being hyperbolic – I literally mean that one of the most common feelings I get when looking at my screen is disgust.

The nonstop anger, the fighting, the hatefulness, the venom . . . it’s a pervasive cloud you can’t escape. I say this even as someone who doesn’t watch news programs or political commentary! But it’s everywhere. And it’s changing us as people.

You don’t need me to tell you this. If you’ve been around for a while, I know you see it too. We’ve become mistrusting, disingenuous, abrasive, intolerant – everyone shouting and no one listening.

So what?

Well, I think we’ve lost, is what. Collectively.

We’ve taken the greatest tool for personal connection the world has ever seen, and we’ve squandered it. We’ve turned it into a poison, and we drink it in, voluntarily, all day every day.

I constantly have this battle of two conflicting pathways inside me: 1) Disconnect completely from the digital space, except where necessary, or 2) Wade in again, creating more communities of people giving back.

Option 2 keeps coming close to happening, but then I remember how hard it was even back in the day when the world was different. Today it could be an exercise in brutality and heartache to create those spaces, and I doubt they’d be nearly as appealing to people now as they were then.

Still, I believe that putting more good into the world is one small way I can fight back against all the bad in the world, so I haven’t ruled it out. But honestly it’s a major struggle with no good answers at the moment. I keep thinking that it may be too late – that we may have lost already.

So I’m not really sure where that leaves me, let alone us. All I know is that I’m pretty sad right now. But in the spirit of the older days of the web, let me share with you a piece of creative beauty I just discovered this week. It’s a couple years old now, but it was new to me, and it’s probably new to you.

When you have 10 quiet minutes, take a look, and think about the days when you could go online and regularly find stuff like this, instead of doomscrolling political outrage.

And hey, if you can, reply with something of beauty you've discovered recently. I wouldn't mind seeing some good things today.


(If you ever stop loving these emails, just unsubscribe here - no hard feelings!)

Nate St. Pierre

I'm an AI developer at the intersection of immersive and emergent storytelling. I help novelists, game designers, and filmmakers vividly imagine their worlds through a set of custom tools I've developed.

Read more from Nate St. Pierre

9 years ago I was talking to the SpaceX Comms team about potentially joining their department. My son was 14 years old and just starting to get interested in space tech, so I asked if I could bring him along. They said yes, and we took a picture in front of HQ in Hawthorne before going inside. Between that moment and today, Josh joined our family group chat with the folks who work in the field, he went with me to the launch of the Mars InSight lander (my cousin worked on it), he started...

I'm restless tonight. Restless and unfocused, but creative. Not a great combination. My output would be muddled. But I can put these feelings to work a different way. Here's what I'll do: I'll create a list of interesting personal questions at the bottom of this email I will choose 5 to answer here for myself You choose up to 5 of your own, and reply back to me with your answers for yourself This is a way for all of us to have a low-stakes connection opportunity. If I get enough interesting...

I may regret this . . . it remains to be seen, haha 😬 But I think we can afford to give away our full $1,000/month YouBots platform to nonprofits for free, based on the money coming in from regular paying customers. For more details on where we are as a business, check out the LinkedIn post I just put up: https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:7322712667536642051/ If you or someone you know works for or with a nonprofit, they'll want to see this. It's probably easiest just to...